Hartville, Ohio is already a destination for bargain hunters thanks to the sprawling Hartville Marketplace and flea market that draws shoppers from across northeast Ohio, and Twice Is Nice Consignments has built its own following a short distance away at 841 Edison Street NW, along Route 619. The shop has been consigning goods in the community since 2000, and in 2017 Amanda took over ownership with a simple operating philosophy: offer a bit of everything for everyone at a price well below retail.
That philosophy shows up directly in the range of merchandise on the floor. Clothing spans juniors, women’s, plus size, and men’s racks, while a dedicated formals section handles prom dresses, bridesmaid gowns, and other special-occasion wear that most consignment shops treat as an afterthought. Beyond apparel, shoppers find home decor, furniture, footwear, and designer and luxury handbags and accessories, all consigned by individual sellers rather than sourced wholesale. A rotating group of local vendors adds another layer to the mix, contributing handmade jewelry, clothing, giftables, and antiques alongside the consigned inventory, so a single visit can turn up factory-made furniture, a designer handbag, and a one-of-a-kind handmade item from a nearby maker all in the same trip.
The shop leans into the resale philosophy explicitly, encouraging shoppers to ask why pay retail when you can shop resale instead, and backs that up with a scale that is unusual for a single-location consignment store: the business works with more than 4,000 individual consignors, which keeps new inventory arriving daily rather than in occasional batches. For anyone consigning rather than shopping, the store maintains a seasonal calendar for timing seasonal items correctly, along with published guidance on how to consign and which categories of items are currently in demand, taking some of the guesswork out of dropping off a first batch of clothing or furniture.
Hours run six days a week: Monday from 11 AM to 8 PM, Tuesday from 9:30 AM to 3 PM, and Wednesday through Saturday from 9:30 AM to 5 PM, with the shop closed Sundays. Consignments are accepted any day the store is open, up until an hour before closing, which gives sellers a wide window to drop off items without needing to plan around a narrow intake schedule the way some consignment shops require.
Beyond the physical Edison Street location, the shop also runs an online shopping platform, extending its reach to buyers who cannot make the trip to Hartville in person but still want access to the same rotating mix of consigned clothing, furniture, and accessories. That combination of a long-running local storefront, a large and active consignor base, and a genuine everyday-to-designer range of merchandise makes the shop a natural stop for anyone already in the area for the Hartville Marketplace or simply looking for a well-stocked consignment shop in Stark County.
Twice Is Nice Consignments is a consignment shop at 841 Edison Street NW in Hartville, Ohio, selling consigned clothing, formal wear, furniture, home decor, and designer accessories from a network of more than 4,000 local consignors, alongside handmade goods from area vendors, six days a week.
