In McCordsville, a fast-growing Hancock County town tucked between Fortville and the shores of Geist Reservoir on the northeast edge of the Indianapolis metro area, Second Stories Antiques gives a second life to furniture, home decor, and collectibles that might otherwise be overlooked. The shop’s name hints at its approach: every dresser, mirror, or set of dishes on the sales floor carries a story from its earlier life, and the goal here is to help each piece begin a new chapter in a customer’s home rather than treat old items as disposable. Shoppers browsing the aisles will find a rotating mix of antique furniture, vintage glassware, decorative accessories, and smaller collectibles, the kind of inventory that changes from one visit to the next because so much of it is one of a kind.
Because the shop operates as a small-town antiques destination rather than a big-box retailer, the buying experience leans on personal service. Shoppers who want to know the background of a specific piece, or who are hunting for something particular, are encouraged to call ahead at 317-335-1674 or check the shop’s Facebook page for the latest photos of new arrivals and any updates to open hours before making the drive out. Following the page is also the easiest way to see fresh finds as soon as they hit the floor, since inventory in a shop like this tends to move quickly once regulars spot something they like.
McCordsville itself sits along the Mount Comfort Road and Broadway corridor in Hancock County, a community that has grown considerably in recent years while still keeping a small-town feel, which makes a locally run antiques shop a natural fit for residents who would rather furnish a home with pieces that have real character than order something mass produced online. For visitors coming from Fortville, Fishers, or the northeast side of Indianapolis, Second Stories offers a reason to slow down and treasure hunt rather than simply check a box on a shopping list.
What sets an antiques shop like this apart from a general resale store is curation. Rather than accepting anything that comes through the door, a shop built around a name like Second Stories tends to be selective about condition and character, favoring pieces with visible craftsmanship, interesting provenance, or a design era that has aged well, whether that means farmhouse-style furniture, mid-century case goods, or smaller decorative antiques that fit a shelf or mantel. That selectivity is part of what keeps return customers coming back, since it means a browsing trip is more likely to turn up something worth taking home than a quick scan through an oversized warehouse would offer.
Locals also appreciate that a shop of this size can turn over its floor plan often, so a visitor who struck out on a Tuesday might find an entirely different selection waiting the following week. That rhythm of donations, estate finds, and new arrivals is part of what keeps a small antiques shop relevant in an era of online resale marketplaces, giving shoppers a reason to actually walk the aisles and handle pieces before deciding.
For anyone in the McCordsville or greater Indianapolis area looking to add a genuine antique or vintage find to their home rather than another new piece off a showroom floor, Second Stories Antiques offers a curated, story-rich alternative worth the visit. In short, Second Stories Antiques is a McCordsville, Indiana shop where secondhand furniture, vintage decor, and collectibles get a second story to tell in someone else’s home.
