Above a pharmacy on one of Princeton’s best-known streets sits a resale shop that has become a fixture for budget-conscious shoppers: Nearly New Shop, located at 234 Nassau Street, up a flight of stairs behind Sante Pharmacy. The shop deals in thrift, consignment, and vintage clothing and accessories, and its second-floor perch just off Princeton University’s campus makes it a natural stop for students, faculty, and longtime residents alike who want quality secondhand pieces in the heart of town.
What sets this stop apart from a typical thrift store is its rotating promotions built around clearing and refreshing inventory. The shop has run a three-dollar sale room featuring deeply discounted racks, and periodically holds a bag day event where shoppers fill a bag for one set price, a format that rewards regulars who come back often to catch the shop between restocks. Following its seasonal fall opening, the shop restocks with new arrivals, meaning the clothing and accessories on the racks shift meaningfully from one visit to the next depending on the time of year.
Nearly New Shop keeps regular hours that make it easy to plan a visit: Monday through Saturday from 10 a.m. to 5 p.m., and Sunday from noon to 5 p.m. Its central Nassau Street address puts it within easy walking distance of Princeton’s downtown shops, restaurants, and the university’s front gates, making a stop here simple to combine with a broader afternoon out in town. Shoppers can also follow along on Instagram at nearlynewprinceton for updates on new inventory, sale events, and restocks between visits, since a shop that depends on consignment and thrift sourcing tends to change quickly and often.
The vintage and consignment mix gives the shop a different character than a straightforward donation-based thrift store; pieces move through consignment arrangements as well as thrifted stock, so shoppers can expect a blend of eras and styles rather than a single narrow category. That range appeals to bargain hunters chasing a deep discount in the sale room as much as it does to shoppers hunting for a specific vintage silhouette or accessory. For anyone in the Princeton, Lawrenceville, or West Windsor area looking to stretch a clothing budget or find something with more character than a mall rack offers, the shop’s location above Sante Pharmacy has become an easy landmark to navigate by.
Given its position along Nassau Street, a short walk from Princeton’s downtown core and the university itself, Nearly New Shop functions as both a practical resale stop and a bit of a local institution, one that longtime Princeton shoppers know to check back on regularly since the upstairs racks rarely look the same two visits in a row. Its blend of thrift pricing, consignment quality, and vintage character keeps it relevant to a wide range of shoppers, from students furnishing a wardrobe on a tight budget to collectors after an older piece with staying power. Reachable at 609-924-5720, the shop welcomes calls for questions on current stock or hours around holidays.
In short, Nearly New Shop is a Nassau Street consignment, thrift, and vintage clothing shop in Princeton, New Jersey known for its affordable sale events and frequently refreshed secondhand inventory.
