Blessed Pope John XXIII Thrift Store occupies Unit 110 in the Plymouth and Regal Plaza at 15200 South Tamiami Trail in Fort Myers, Florida, and its mission is stated plainly on its own site: it sells donated quality clothing, furniture, and household items to fund Catholic education and local community outreach. That is a more specific purpose than the average secondhand shop claims, and it shapes how the store operates from intake to checkout.
The sales floor covers a wide range of secondhand categories. Shoppers will find clothing and footwear, accessories, furniture, kitchenware and other household goods, books, media including DVDs, CDs, and Blu-rays, electronics, sporting goods, musical instruments, office equipment, and collectibles. That breadth means a single visit can turn up anything from a stack of paperbacks to a dining chair to a used guitar, which is part of what keeps regular thrift shoppers coming back to see what has arrived since their last stop. The store is also selective about what it takes in: building materials, unframed mirrors, mattresses and box springs, non working electronics, computers and printers, and child safety items like car seats, booster seats, and helmets are all turned away, a policy that keeps the floor stocked with items that are actually resalable and safe to pass along to another family.
For donors with larger items, the store offers furniture pickup by appointment, though the policy is specific: pickups are limited to ground floor units, or homes and apartments with working elevator access, since a small thrift store staff cannot always manage stairs with heavy furniture. For anyone disposing of items the store cannot accept as a donation, a separate paid disposal service is available, giving the community a responsible option for hauling away goods that would otherwise end up illegally dumped or sent straight to a landfill.
Because the store is parish sponsored, its retail operation doubles as a fundraising engine for the Blessed Pope John XXIII Catholic community, channeling proceeds toward Catholic education and outreach programs that serve the wider Fort Myers area rather than any single congregation alone. Regular shoppers can also join a frequent shopper loyalty program built around cards that do not expire, a small but meaningful gesture in an industry where punch cards and rewards programs often reset or lapse. The store also relies on volunteers across multiple roles, from sorting and pricing donations to staffing the register, which keeps overhead low and lets more of every sale flow back into the store’s stated charitable purpose.
Fort Myers is one of Southwest Florida’s larger population centers, and the Tamiami Trail corridor where the store sits is a major commercial spine running through the region, making the shop accessible to shoppers and donors from across Lee County. Anyone with items to donate, drop off, or ask about pickup can call the store directly at (239) 433-4097 to confirm current details before making a trip.
Blessed Pope John XXIII Thrift Store is a Fort Myers, Florida thrift shop that channels proceeds from donated clothing, furniture, household goods, and media sales directly into funding Catholic education and community outreach in Southwest Florida.
