Vintage apparel shoppers in Hudson County know Another Man’s Treasure as the Montgomery Street stop for secondhand fashion in downtown Jersey City, New Jersey, a compact storefront that keeps some of the longest hours of any resale shop in the area: 11 in the morning to 8 at night Monday through Saturday, and 11 to 6 on Sunday, seven days a week without a single closed day built into the weekly schedule. The shop’s focus is squarely on vintage and secondhand clothing and accessories rather than general antiques or home goods, curated for a downtown Jersey City customer base that skews toward the PATH commuting crowd heading into and out of Manhattan, a neighborhood where quick access to a well edited clothing rack matters as much as the clothing itself. Unlike many small vintage shops that exist only as a physical storefront, Another Man’s Treasure also runs a Shopify powered online store, letting customers outside walking distance of Montgomery Street browse and buy pieces remotely, and it sells digital gift cards through Square for anyone who wants to give vintage shopping as a present without guessing at sizing or style. The shop keeps an active presence on Instagram and TikTok under the handle amtvintage, using both platforms to preview new stock arrivals and highlight standout pieces before they ever reach the sales floor, a strategy that lets a small brick and mortar shop build a following well beyond its immediate neighborhood. That social media first approach to previewing inventory is itself a point of difference from most resale shops of similar size, many of which rely entirely on walk in browsing rather than building an audience that watches for new drops online first. Jersey City’s downtown has become one of the most active secondhand and vintage retail pockets in New Jersey over the past decade, driven by a young, style conscious population living in the high rises and brownstones near the Grove Street PATH station, and Another Man’s Treasure has positioned itself squarely inside that demand rather than competing with the traditional antique malls found further out in suburban New Jersey. The seven day, extended evening hours in particular set the shop apart from typical antique and vintage retailers, many of which close by five or six and skip Sundays entirely, a schedule built around commuters who want to shop after a workday rather than only on weekends. Anyone hunting for a specific era of clothing, a particular designer label, or simply a well curated rack of secondhand pieces without digging through disorganized bins will find the Montgomery Street location, and its parallel online shop, structured for quick, focused browsing rather than an all day treasure hunt. Customers can reach the shop directly at 201-860-9990 to ask about current stock before making a trip in, and the mailing list mentioned on the shop’s own site offers another way to hear about new arrivals between visits. Another Man’s Treasure is a seven day a week vintage clothing shop in downtown Jersey City, New Jersey, combining long walk in hours, an online Shopify store, and an active Instagram and TikTok presence to serve a fashion focused urban customer base.
Another Man’s Treasure
By anothermanstreasure
More listings by this vendor
Vintage apparel shoppers in Hudson County know Another Man’s Treasure as the Montgomery Street stop for secondhand fashion in downtown Jersey City, New Jersey, a compact storefront that keeps some of the longest hours of any resale shop in the area: 11 in the morning to 8 at night Monday through Saturday, and 11 to 6 on Sunday, seven days a week without a single closed day built into the weekly schedule. The shop’s focus is squarely on vintage and secondhand clothing and accessories rather than general antiques or home goods, curated for a downtown Jersey City customer base that skews toward the PATH commuting crowd heading into and out of Manhattan, a neighborhood where quick access to a well edited clothing rack matters as much as the clothing itself. Unlike many small vintage shops that exist only as a physical storefront, Another Man’s Treasure also runs a Shopify powered online store, letting customers outside walking distance of Montgomery Street browse and buy pieces remotely, and it sells digital gift cards through Square for anyone who wants to give vintage shopping as a present without guessing at sizing or style. The shop keeps an active presence on Instagram and TikTok under the handle amtvintage, using both platforms to preview new stock arrivals and highlight standout pieces before they ever reach the sales floor, a strategy that lets a small brick and mortar shop build a following well beyond its immediate neighborhood. That social media first approach to previewing inventory is itself a point of difference from most resale shops of similar size, many of which rely entirely on walk in browsing rather than building an audience that watches for new drops online first. Jersey City’s downtown has become one of the most active secondhand and vintage retail pockets in New Jersey over the past decade, driven by a young, style conscious population living in the high rises and brownstones near the Grove Street PATH station, and Another Man’s Treasure has positioned itself squarely inside that demand rather than competing with the traditional antique malls found further out in suburban New Jersey. The seven day, extended evening hours in particular set the shop apart from typical antique and vintage retailers, many of which close by five or six and skip Sundays entirely, a schedule built around commuters who want to shop after a workday rather than only on weekends. Anyone hunting for a specific era of clothing, a particular designer label, or simply a well curated rack of secondhand pieces without digging through disorganized bins will find the Montgomery Street location, and its parallel online shop, structured for quick, focused browsing rather than an all day treasure hunt. Customers can reach the shop directly at 201-860-9990 to ask about current stock before making a trip in, and the mailing list mentioned on the shop’s own site offers another way to hear about new arrivals between visits. Another Man’s Treasure is a seven day a week vintage clothing shop in downtown Jersey City, New Jersey, combining long walk in hours, an online Shopify store, and an active Instagram and TikTok presence to serve a fashion focused urban customer base.
Your shop would look great here!
Promote your shop with Re:Source Roadmap, and we’ll put it in front of tons of people searching for experiences like yours
Get started