When Sylvia Gedeon opened Amelia’s Attic in 1993, she introduced Fernandina Beach to something the area had not seen before: its first dedicated furniture consignment store. More than three decades later, the shop still operates at 2164 Sadler Road on Amelia Island, just a few miles from the historic downtown district and the island’s beaches, and it remains a family affair, with Sylvia and her daughter Jennifer working alongside a staff that knows the inventory well enough to help customers track down exactly the piece they have in mind.
The business describes its approach as a unique mix of new and consignment items, and that blend is really what defines the shopping experience. Alongside competitively priced new furniture, the store carries gently used consignment pieces that arrive from local sellers looking to pass along quality furnishings, plus a rotating selection of wall art, lamps, and home accessories that round out a full room rather than just a single piece. Because new consignment items arrive daily, the sales floor looks different on any given visit, which means regular customers often stop in specifically to see what has just come through the door rather than treating it as a one time destination.
Amelia’s Attic is open Tuesday through Saturday from 10 a.m. to 5:30 p.m., giving both residents and the steady stream of visitors to Amelia Island and nearby Fernandina Beach a wide window to browse. Shoppers with questions about specific inventory, or those interested in learning more about consigning their own furniture, can call the store directly at 904-277-2095 or reach out by email at photostoattic@gmail.com. The consignment side of the business gives local sellers a straightforward way to pass along furniture and decor they no longer need, while giving buyers access to well cared for secondhand pieces at a fraction of retail cost, a system that has clearly sustained the store since its founding in the early 1990s.
What distinguishes Amelia’s Attic from a typical furniture retailer is the combination of longevity and hands on family ownership. Being the first furniture consignment store to serve the area gave the business an early foothold in a niche that blends retail and resale, and the continued involvement of the founder’s family suggests a level of institutional knowledge about both the inventory and the customers that a purely corporate furniture chain would struggle to match. The store emphasizes a pleasant atmosphere for browsing and treats service as a specialty rather than an afterthought, which matters in a category where buyers often want guidance on scale, condition, and style before committing to a piece as large as a sofa or dining set.
For anyone furnishing a home on Amelia Island or in greater Fernandina Beach, whether searching for an affordable new piece, a well maintained secondhand find, or simply browsing lamps and wall art to finish a room, Amelia’s Attic offers a locally established option with three decades of continuous operation behind it. Its Tuesday through Saturday hours make it easy to work into a weekend island visit or a weekday errand run near Sadler Road. Amelia’s Attic Furniture is a family owned consignment and new furniture store in Fernandina Beach, Florida, that has offered Amelia Island shoppers an ever changing mix of furnishings, lighting, and home decor since 1993.
