Tucked into a stretch of North Cleveland Avenue in North Fort Myers, All Souls Episcopal Thrift Store operates as a ministry of All Souls Episcopal Church, with proceeds directly supporting the parish’s outreach programs and community initiatives rather than any private owner. The store sits at 14640 N. Cleveland Ave., a short drive from downtown Fort Myers across the Caloosahatchee River, and welcomes shoppers looking for gently used clothing, linens, furniture, arts and crafts supplies, boutique jewelry, and a rotating mix of brand name fashion finds. Because everything on the racks and shelves comes from community donations, the inventory changes constantly, and regular browsers often describe stumbling onto genuinely surprising treasures among the everyday basics.
The store keeps a schedule built around volunteer availability: it is open Monday, Tuesday, Thursday, Friday, and Saturday from 9 a.m. to 3 p.m., with a shorter Wednesday shift from noon to 3 p.m. Donations are accepted daily from 9 a.m. to noon, except on Wednesdays and Sundays, giving neighbors a reliable window to drop off clean, gently used items rather than leaving bags at the door after hours. Anyone planning a visit is encouraged to call ahead at 239-656-6229 to confirm current hours, since a volunteer run operation can occasionally shift its schedule around holidays or staffing.
What sets this thrift store apart from a typical secondhand shop is its staffing model. Rather than paid retail employees, the store is run by what the church itself calls a loving group of women and men who give their time to sort donations, price merchandise, and greet customers, with ministry coordinators Patrice Swift and Carla Walther helping guide the day to day operation. That volunteer backbone means every dollar spent in the store cycles back into the church’s charitable work, funding outreach efforts and parish programs that serve the broader North Fort Myers community. Shoppers are not just finding a deal on a lamp or a coat; they are directly supporting a local congregation’s mission to help people in need.
For anyone in the North Fort Myers or greater Fort Myers area hunting for affordable furniture, household linens, craft supplies, or a fresh piece of jewelry, this thrift store offers an easy, low pressure browsing experience close to Cleveland Avenue’s commercial corridor. It is a practical stop for budget conscious shoppers, families furnishing a first apartment, crafters looking for raw materials, or anyone who simply enjoys the hunt of secondhand shopping, and every purchase carries the added benefit of feeding straight back into local church ministry work. The church also actively recruits new volunteers, so those who enjoy being part of a community and want a hands on way to give back can reach out directly to the church office at 239-997-7685 or by email at admin@allsoulsnfm.org to learn about open shifts sorting donations, working the register, or helping with display and organization.
Because the shop depends on ongoing donations, residents cleaning out closets, garages, or storage units are welcome to bring gently used furniture, clothing, linens, and craft materials during the posted donation hours, keeping the inventory fresh for the next round of shoppers. That cycle of giving and shopping is really the heart of the operation: a neighborhood thrift store where every donated coat or end table becomes both an affordable find for one family and a funding source for the church’s broader outreach. All Souls Episcopal Thrift Store is a volunteer run secondhand shop in North Fort Myers, Florida, that sells donated clothing, furniture, linens, jewelry, and crafts to fund All Souls Episcopal Church’s community outreach programs.
