On North Frontage Road in Michigan City, Indiana, a lakefront town on the Lake Michigan shoreline in LaPorte County, Nanni’s Over the Fence Antiques runs a large single venue devoted almost entirely to furniture and decorative pieces spanning several distinct design eras. Rather than specializing narrowly, the shop’s own description of its stock, a large venue of antiques covering farmhouse, mid century modern, art nouveau, art deco, Victorian, and industrial styles, signals a deliberately wide net cast across more than a century of design history. That breadth means a shopper drawn in by clean mid century lines can wander a few steps further and find ornate Victorian details or raw industrial metal pieces in the same building, giving the shop an appeal that spans several different collector tastes rather than locking in on just one era.
The shop has built real credibility with its customer base, carrying a 98 percent recommendation rate across 67 reviews on its Facebook page, a strong showing for a secondhand furniture business where condition, pricing, and staff helpfulness vary widely from one antique shop to the next. Recent posts from the shop keep followers updated on daily opening times, including a note letting customers know the doors open at 9 in the morning, a useful detail for early risers planning a morning antiquing run before the rest of a day’s errands in Michigan City. With more than 2,300 people following the shop on Facebook, Nanni’s Over the Fence has built a following well beyond a purely local customer base, likely helped along by Michigan City’s steady stream of visitors headed to the nearby Indiana Dunes and Lake Michigan beaches.
Farmhouse style furniture in particular has surged in popularity for home renovators over the past several years, and a shop stocking both genuine farmhouse pieces and mid century modern alongside it gives buyers doing a full home refresh a single stop for mixing eras rather than needing to hit several specialty shops. The art nouveau, art deco, and Victorian pieces in the mix serve a different kind of shopper entirely, often collectors specifically hunting for detailed period furniture or decorative accents rather than everyday functional pieces, and having both audiences served under one roof is part of what makes this venue stand out from a typical single style antique shop.
Michigan City sits along the LaPorte County lakeshore not far from the Indiana Dunes National Park, making Nanni’s Over the Fence a reasonable stop for visitors already headed to the area’s beaches and trails, as well as a destination in its own right for antique hunters across northwest Indiana. Current hours and any changes to opening times are best confirmed through the shop’s active Facebook page before making a special trip, since the business posts regular updates there rather than maintaining a separate hours listing elsewhere. In short, Nanni’s Over the Fence is a large Michigan City, Indiana antiques venue spanning farmhouse, mid century modern, art nouveau, art deco, Victorian, and industrial furniture, backed by a 98 percent customer recommendation rate across dozens of reviews.
