Welcome to Mimi’s Attic, Ithaca’s premier destination for quality pre-loved furniture, unique vintage decor, household goods, and handcrafted finds from Finger Lakes makers. Located at 401 Elmira Road in Buttermilk Falls Plaza (Units 2–4), our eco-friendly consignment showroom offers a curated shopping experience designed to help you furnish your space with character, style, and history. Whether you are searching for distinctive home accessories, solid secondhand furnishings, or hidden architectural antiques in Tompkins County, our daily updated inventory keeps quality goods in circulation while lowering your environmental footprint.
Selling and consigning your home goods with us is simple, transparent, and community-focused. Our dedicated on-site Intake department in Unit 3 welcomes sellers Thursday through Monday, making it effortless to rehome your furniture and household treasures. Beyond our physical showroom, Mimi’s Attic offers 24/7 online shopping through our digital storefront, letting you discover new arrivals from anywhere in Central New York. We are also proud to showcase products from local artisans, further strengthening the vibrant circular economy of the Ithaca community.
Originally founded by Kelly Moreland and named in loving memory of her grandmother, Ethel “Mimi” Hinkel—a full-time school teacher, mother, and lifelong enthusiast of flea markets and cozy, beautiful spaces—Mimi’s Attic is proudly owned and operated by local partners Ian Rydgren and Amanda Oczkowski. Deeply rooted in the region, Ian and Amanda bring a shared passion for community connection, quality design, and local history to every corner of the store. Visit our Ithaca showroom today or explore our shop online to find something extraordinary for your home!
