Lily’s Consignment Shoppe has been a fixture in Canandaigua and the wider Finger Lakes region since 1989, long enough that it now counts as a multi-decade institution in a retail category where many shops open and close within a few seasons. The business takes its name from the owner’s grandmother, a personal touch that runs through a store built around family-friendly, budget-conscious secondhand shopping rather than high-end designer resale. Inside, shoppers find clothing sized for the entire family, from children through adults, alongside a rotating selection of fine jewelry, small furniture pieces, household decor, knickknacks, and other collectibles that arrive through the shop’s ongoing consignment relationships with local sellers.
The shop presents itself deliberately as a step above the typical thrift store experience, describing its offerings as gently used quality merchandise displayed in a bright, clean setting rather than piled on tables. That positioning matters in a consignment business, where the appeal depends on convincing both sellers and buyers that items are curated and cared for rather than simply dumped and sorted. Because Lily’s operates on consignment, local residents looking to part with clothing, jewelry, or smaller furnishings can bring items in to be sold on their behalf, giving the shop a steady, community-driven supply chain that keeps the sales floor changing from one visit to the next.
Lily’s keeps accessible hours for a small-town consignment shop, open Monday through Friday from 9:30 in the morning to 5 in the evening and Saturday from 9 to 5, a schedule that accommodates both weekday errands and weekend browsing without requiring an appointment. Over its long run, the business has grown enough to relocate to a larger Canandaigua location, a move covered by local media and one that reflects steady demand in a city that draws both year-round Finger Lakes residents and seasonal visitors exploring Ontario County’s antiquing and shopping circuit. That growth history distinguishes Lily’s from newer consignment ventures still building a customer base, since nearly four decades in business means multiple generations of local families have likely both bought from and sold to the shop.
The Finger Lakes region carries a strong secondhand and antiquing culture, with Canandaigua sitting near several other consignment and antique destinations along the lake, and Lily’s has carved out its niche by focusing specifically on affordable, family-oriented merchandise rather than trying to compete with higher-end antique dealers or specialty vintage boutiques nearby. That focus on practical, everyday consignment, covering clothing for kids and adults alike plus jewelry and small home goods, keeps the shop relevant to a broad cross-section of local shoppers rather than a narrow collector audience. The shop maintains an active Facebook presence where staff post new consignment arrivals and updates for regulars who like to check in before making the trip.
For families and individuals across Ontario County looking to buy or sell gently used clothing, jewelry, and household items at reasonable prices, Lily’s Consignment Shoppe offers nearly four decades of trusted, community-rooted consignment service in the heart of Canandaigua.
