On Coy Street in downtown Canandaigua, in the heart of New York’s Finger Lakes region, Canandaigua Record Exchange keeps vinyl culture alive with a curated selection of new and used LPs alongside CDs, drawing shoppers who want to flip through crates rather than scroll through a streaming queue. The shop bills itself as Canandaigua’s chosen spot for new and used vinyl, and the label has stuck: the store has been voted Best Specialty Shop in local readers polls in both 2021 and 2023, with finalist nods in 2020, 2022, and 2024, a run of recognition that points to steady community loyalty rather than a single lucky year. Doors open Wednesday through Friday from noon to seven in the evening, stretch to a full workday on Saturday from ten to seven, and wind down on Sunday from noon to five, with Monday and Tuesday reserved for restocking and record hunting rather than retail. Beyond the walk-in browsing experience, the shop runs an online storefront through RSD MRKT, the Record Store Day marketplace platform, so collectors outside the Finger Lakes can order and have vinyl shipped anywhere in the country. What distinguishes this shop from a typical used record store is its role as a live music hub: Canandaigua Record Exchange regularly hosts listening parties and release-day events tied to major album drops, and it has offered exclusive vinyl variants tied to artists such as Billy Strings, Beabadoobee, and Mike D that were only available to customers who showed up in person for the event. That in-store event calendar turns record shopping into something closer to a small community gathering than a simple transaction, with regulars showing up as much for the shared listening experience as for the crate-digging itself. The shop also sells gift certificates, a detail that signals a steady base of returning customers and gift-giving shoppers who trust the store to introduce a music lover to something new. Canandaigua itself sits at the northern tip of Canandaigua Lake, one of the smaller cities anchoring the Finger Lakes wine and tourism corridor, and a record shop with this kind of specialty focus and local award history gives visitors another reason to make a stop downtown beyond the lakefront and the wineries. Whether someone is searching for a specific used pressing, hunting for a Record Store Day exclusive, or just wants to spend an afternoon flipping through new arrivals, Canandaigua Record Exchange offers a genuine independent record store experience anchored in the Finger Lakes, with a loyal enough local following to have been recognized as the region’s best specialty shop more than once. That combination of a physical crate-digging destination, a shippable online catalog, and a regular schedule of artist-tied listening events is what makes Canandaigua Record Exchange a standout stop for vinyl collectors well beyond Ontario County.
More listings by this vendor
On Coy Street in downtown Canandaigua, in the heart of New York’s Finger Lakes region, Canandaigua Record Exchange keeps vinyl culture alive with a curated selection of new and used LPs alongside CDs, drawing shoppers who want to flip through crates rather than scroll through a streaming queue. The shop bills itself as Canandaigua’s chosen spot for new and used vinyl, and the label has stuck: the store has been voted Best Specialty Shop in local readers polls in both 2021 and 2023, with finalist nods in 2020, 2022, and 2024, a run of recognition that points to steady community loyalty rather than a single lucky year. Doors open Wednesday through Friday from noon to seven in the evening, stretch to a full workday on Saturday from ten to seven, and wind down on Sunday from noon to five, with Monday and Tuesday reserved for restocking and record hunting rather than retail. Beyond the walk-in browsing experience, the shop runs an online storefront through RSD MRKT, the Record Store Day marketplace platform, so collectors outside the Finger Lakes can order and have vinyl shipped anywhere in the country. What distinguishes this shop from a typical used record store is its role as a live music hub: Canandaigua Record Exchange regularly hosts listening parties and release-day events tied to major album drops, and it has offered exclusive vinyl variants tied to artists such as Billy Strings, Beabadoobee, and Mike D that were only available to customers who showed up in person for the event. That in-store event calendar turns record shopping into something closer to a small community gathering than a simple transaction, with regulars showing up as much for the shared listening experience as for the crate-digging itself. The shop also sells gift certificates, a detail that signals a steady base of returning customers and gift-giving shoppers who trust the store to introduce a music lover to something new. Canandaigua itself sits at the northern tip of Canandaigua Lake, one of the smaller cities anchoring the Finger Lakes wine and tourism corridor, and a record shop with this kind of specialty focus and local award history gives visitors another reason to make a stop downtown beyond the lakefront and the wineries. Whether someone is searching for a specific used pressing, hunting for a Record Store Day exclusive, or just wants to spend an afternoon flipping through new arrivals, Canandaigua Record Exchange offers a genuine independent record store experience anchored in the Finger Lakes, with a loyal enough local following to have been recognized as the region’s best specialty shop more than once. That combination of a physical crate-digging destination, a shippable online catalog, and a regular schedule of artist-tied listening events is what makes Canandaigua Record Exchange a standout stop for vinyl collectors well beyond Ontario County.
Your event would look great here!
Promote your event with Re:Source Roadmap, and we’ll put it in front of tons of people searching for experiences like yours
Get started
TASTEFUL THREADS VINTAGE MARKET
by hello@resourceroadmap.com
TASTEFUL THREADS VINTAGE MARKET
by hello@resourceroadmap.com