Mystic’s Greenmanville Avenue is best known for the seaport museum crowds it draws, but a few doors down at number 22, Pennywise Consignment has spent decades quietly building a different kind of destination: a resale shop for designer clothing, handbags, jewelry, and accessories aimed at both women and men. The shop has been operating since 1988, giving it a run of nearly four decades in the pre-owned designer market, well before resale fashion became the mainstream trend it is today. That longevity is unusual for a consignment business, a category where storefronts tend to turn over every few years, and it points to a shop that has kept its sourcing and pricing dialed in through changing fashion cycles.
Pennywise deals specifically in current and recent styles from recognizable labels rather than general secondhand clothing, positioning itself closer to a curated resale boutique than a broad thrift store. The consignment side of the business runs on an appointment basis, with sellers able to book, reschedule, or check on the status of their consigned items directly through the shop’s website. That structure gives the store more control over what reaches the floor, which in turn supports its focus on current styles and recognizable brands rather than a grab-bag of donated goods.
The shop keeps steady daily hours, open Monday through Saturday from 10 a.m. to 5 p.m., making it easy to fold a visit into a day trip to Mystic alongside the seaport or the aquarium. Shoppers can reach the store directly at 860-572-9232 to ask about current inventory, consignment appointments, or gift card purchases, which the shop also offers. Pennywise maintains an active presence on Facebook and Instagram and has more recently added an email newsletter, giving regular customers a way to hear about new arrivals or promotions between visits rather than relying solely on walking past the storefront.
Consignment shops that specialize in designer goods depend heavily on a steady supply of quality pieces from sellers who trust the shop to price and present their items well, and a business that has held onto that trust since 1988 has clearly built a reliable base of consignors in the region. For shoppers, that translates into a rotating selection of handbags, jewelry, and clothing from well-known labels at a fraction of original retail, refreshed continually as new consignments come through the appointment process.
Whether someone is passing through Mystic for the day or lives locally and checks in regularly, Pennywise Consignment offers a dependable source for pre-owned designer fashion in a part of Connecticut better known for maritime history than high-end resale. Pennywise Consignment on Greenmanville Avenue in Mystic, Connecticut has sold pre-owned designer clothing, handbags, jewelry, and accessories through an appointment-based consignment model since 1988.
