Super Chance Consignment has been buying and selling secondhand goods in Victoria, British Columbia since 1975, making it one of the longer running consignment operations on Vancouver Island. The shop is located at 10-435 Simcoe Street, tucked into Victoria’s James Bay neighborhood just south of the downtown core and within easy walking distance of the Inner Harbour, a spot that puts it among the residential streets and small local businesses that give James Bay its village like feel despite sitting minutes from the legislature buildings and the tourist heavy waterfront.
As a consignment shop, Super Chance works differently than a straight donation based thrift store: sellers bring in their own secondhand items, the store puts them out for sale, and the original owner receives a share of the proceeds once something sells, rather than simply giving goods away for free. The shop pays particular attention to higher end items, offering appointments for consignors who want to bring in higher value pieces rather than working strictly on a first come basis for everything that comes through the door. Prospective consignors are asked to email the store ahead of time to arrange a drop off slot, and anyone expecting a payout is asked to give advance notice by phone or email rather than expecting an on the spot cash exchange, a policy that keeps the consignment process organized for a shop that has clearly been refining its systems for decades.
The store keeps generous hours for a small independent shop, opening Monday through Saturday from 10 a.m. to 5 p.m. and Sunday from 10 a.m. to 4 p.m., with slightly shortened hours of 10 a.m. to 3 p.m. on statutory holidays. That kind of seven day a week availability is unusual among small consignment shops and makes Super Chance an easy stop for both locals running weekend errands and visitors exploring James Bay on a day trip from the harbour.
Having operated continuously in Victoria for roughly five decades, Super Chance has watched the city’s secondhand retail landscape shift dramatically, from the rise and fall of countless competitors to changing tastes in what shoppers consider worth reselling, all while staying locally owned and operated rather than folding into a larger chain. That kind of longevity is rare in the resale business, where margins are thin and inventory depends entirely on what comes through the door, and it speaks to a shop that has built real trust with a base of repeat consignors and shoppers over multiple generations of Victoria residents.
Because inventory turns over based entirely on what local sellers bring in, the selection at Super Chance changes constantly, rewarding shoppers who make a habit of stopping by regularly rather than expecting to find any one specific item on demand. That unpredictability is part of the draw for many consignment shoppers, who treat a visit to a shop like this as a small treasure hunt rather than a targeted errand. For anyone in Victoria looking to consign quality secondhand goods, particularly higher value pieces that warrant a scheduled appointment, or simply looking to browse a well established shop’s ever changing shelves, Super Chance offers a straightforward and steady option.
In short, Super Chance Consignment is a family style, independently run consignment shop in Victoria’s James Bay neighborhood that has bought, sold, and recirculated secondhand goods on Simcoe Street since 1975, pairing broad weekly hours with an appointment based system for higher end consignments.
